A Slice of Perfection: The Top Pizzeria in Every State

33/50 Previous Next

© Prince Street Pizza

New York: Prince Street Pizza

In New York City, Prince Street Pizza has become a mecca for lovers of Sicilian-style pan pizza, famous for its thick, fluffy crust and outrageously good pepperoni squares. This tiny Soho shop was ranked 7th on Yelp’s 2024 list of the top 100 pizzerias in the country, thanks to a devoted fan base that can’t get enough of its signature Spicy Spring pie. That iconic slice is piled with crispy-edged “roni cup” pepperonis that curl into little bowls of delicious grease as they bake, making for a gloriously indulgent bite. Prince Street’s popularity has even spawned a few outposts in other cities, but nothing beats grabbing a square slice from the original shop, fresh out of the oven on a bustling Manhattan night.