A Slice of Perfection: The Top Pizzeria in Every State

36/50 Previous Next

© Paulie Gee’s

Ohio: Paulie Gee's

Columbus, Ohio’s installment of Paulie Gee’s (an offshoot of the famed Brooklyn original) has quickly become a hotspot — especially for those who like a little heat on their pizza. The menu features everything from ultra-crispy Detroit-style square pies to classic wood-fired rounds, and nearly every offering can be made in a vegan-friendly version too. For spice lovers, the must-try is the Hellboy, a fiery creation with tomatoes, hot soppressata salami, mozzarella, Parmesan, and a drizzle of hot honey to balance the heat. There’s also the “Hellified” Porkpie White, which adds spicy sausage, basil, red onion, sliced garlic, and more hot honey to a mozzarella base. With its wide variety and bold flavors, Paulie Gee’s Short North has firmly established itself as Ohio’s top spot for adventurous pizza eaters.